The fan moves the air that the cooler needs. Its performance is set by diameter, blade count and pitch, so a fan that is close but not identical will fit and still leave the machine running hot at full load. Most failures start as a cracked blade and end as a vibration that takes the bearing with it.
Confirm the diameter, the blade count, the rotation direction and the hub bore before ordering. Check the shroud clearance and the bearing play at the same time - a worn bearing destroys a new fan quickly.